This greatly dampens vibrations and makes for a springy and comfortable ride. If you’re over around 180-200 pounds, you’ll probably want to go with a frame with a strength rating on the stronger side. The raw material is expensive as well. Where do you stand on the carbon vs aluminum bike frame debate? Alloy bikes tend to fail pretty catastrophically, unlike steel which can often bend and stay together, alloy frames will tend to have clean breaks. Aluminum alloy contains very little if any iron so it doesn’t rust either. Subscribe to my Newsletter for New Posts and Exclusive Content! Racers or those who care about keeping time of their rides can also benefit from the stiffer, more efficient ride that high-end aluminum frames offer. The Specialized Allez Elite forms … I wonder how they achieve that weight? Adding these elements increases the strength to weight ratio of the steel. Most bamboo bikes are made by starting with strong bamboo poles then binding the joints together with fiber and resin. The reason is that aluminum is a strong enough material to support racks and panniers without damaging the frame. These are kind of a novelty at this point. Stiff frames make for a harsh ride because the shocks and vibrations from the road transfer straight through the frame to your body. Generally, an aluminum frame can handle a harder impact force than a carbon frame without cracking or breaking. Much stronger than rust. It is usually mixed with carbon and traces of other elements to increase strength and reduce weight. This creates a comfortable frame without sacrificing efficiency or responsiveness. You can also gently press on any areas where you suspect that the frame is cracked. After all, it’s the cheapest bike frame material. We ride for fun or transportation. Steel vs. Aluminum Bike Frames. If you decide to do this, remember that you’re taking a chance. Mountain Bike Frame 26 27 5inch Aluminum Alloy Mtb Road Bikes Sho Philippines Should you choose a steel aluminium titanium or carbon road bike cc steel vs aluminum bike frames mission bicycle bike frame materials how to choose a carbon vs aluminum mountain bike frames the showdown gearlab. This makes the ride more comfortable while riding over bumps or rough roads. If you fall between two sizes, it’s generally better to choose the smaller frame. Recreational riders probably won’t notice a difference or won’t care. After enough miles, the material eventually cracks and fails. Titanium is also known for its smooth ride quality. Advantages and Disadvantages of Steel Frames. The material itself is expensive. You’ll probably maintain a higher average speed as well. Thousands of these filaments are combined to form a tow or ribbon. Of the two, 6061 is slightly superior due to its lower weight. That says something about the material. If you don’t really care if the bike lasts for the rest of your life and you value weight over anything else, aluminum or carbon fiber frames may be for you. This means you don’t have to worry about your frame getting wet or exposed to salty sea air, chemicals, or road salt and rusting. It can’t handle as hard of impacts without cracking. Unfortunately, carbon fiber is not an environmentally friendly material. If you’re unsure, check with a professional. This process is more expensive than just buying a new frame. Carbon fiber is manufactured by weaving fibers together in sheets. If you plan to do any bicycle touring or bikepacking, you’ll want to choose an aluminum frame over carbon. If you’re on a tight budget, you’re probably better off staying away from carbon frames or buying used. Some frames are made by bonding together individual carbon fiber tubes with a type of glued insert. If you treat it properly, you could get decades of use out of it. Often, the tubes are of 3AL-2.5V while dropouts and other peripheral sections are made of 6AL-4V. It’s difficult to tell by looking at the frame. Where do you stand on the steel vs aluminum bike frame debate? For example, the type of resin used, the thickness of the layers, the construction style, the way the material is heated, the direction of the fibers, the grade of carbon fiber, and the density and types of fibers used all play a role in the ride characteristics, durability, stiffness, and comfort of the finished frame. Titanium bike frames have two main drawbacks. Privacy Policy. Carbon fiber is basically a plastic that is reinforced with super strong fibers. When you weld aluminum, you must re temper or heat treat the whole frame to strengthen the metal. 7005 is an alloy of mainly aluminium and zinc. In reference to bicycle frames, “alloy” means aluminum alloy, unless the description includes another type of material. Carbon fiber bike frames vary greatly in price. This is probably the reason that the pros all use carbon frames these days. Titanium is also corrosion-resistant. They can crack or break. No bolts are required. These vary in weight and strength. This material is then shaped into bike frames using molds and heat. Since the backbone of any bike is its frame, it can be enlightening to understand how it's made and what that means for you, the cyclist. Titanium really offers the best of all worlds. Read the review: Specialized Allez E5 Elite. It was true 20 years ago when aluminum frames were unrefined and still being built using traditional designs. Aluminum frames often cost half as much as carbon frames. For some of us, it’s the reason we ride a bike instead of drive or take the bus. The process is made slightly more complicated because titanium reacts with oxygen. a metal that is mixed with other elements to improve the metal’s characteristics. The tubes throughout a frame will be butted, meaning the wall thickness will vary - mo… Aluminum is actually a fairly soft metal, so … Carbon fiber can fail catastrophically and without warning. For more info, check out this guide to inspecting a carbon frame. In fact, many manufacturers even offer a lifetime guarantee against defects. For building bike frames, titanium is often alloyed together with aluminum and traces of other elements. It offers an excellent combination of affordability, durability, and ride quality. In addition, the tubes are double butted, which means they're thicker at the welds for strength, and thinner in between to save weight. Steel and titanium frames can generally support more weight because they are able to flex more without failing. Having said this, even though carbon fiber is an incredibly strong material, it is more brittle than aluminum. Aluminum frames are generally welded, which makes them cheaper to produce. The material is lightweight, stiff, affordable, and easy to work with. The type of connection used doesn’t really affect the way the bike rides. For the consumer, it's unlikely you will be able to tell the difference in a finished product. Even though aluminum is an easier material to work with than carbon fiber, it can’t be manipulated and fine tuned quite as much. Without it, you just have a pile of parts. Aluminum, on the other hand, fatigues over time. Manufacturers have to sell bicycles. Heat pressing, drilling, demolding, de-flashing, finishing, etc. Consider how often you crash, whether you’re an elite rider or more casual, how much weight matters, and your budget. They can just take more of a beating. Brazing sticks the frame tubes with a molten filler material. Hopefully, this guide helps you decide on the best frame material for your next bike. These joints are similar to carbon fiber. Hi-tensile steel is a heavier and cheaper type of steel that is used to build lower-end bike frames. Tip: If you’re a particularly heavy rider, you may want to consider a touring bike. Amateur racers who buy their own bikes may also enjoy the cost savings. This means that you don’t have to worry about it weakening over time. In fact, it is one of the most recyclable materials out there. Carbon frames offer a more comfortable ride than aluminum frames. It takes some skill. It offers an excellent combination of affordability, durability, and ride quality. Alloys are metals with other elements added to improve properties like strength or stiffness. 6061 and 7005 are the two most common aluminum alloys used for frame building. For some types of cycling, steel or titanium are better choices. Most carbon frames can’t accept racks and panniers because they put too much stress on the frame tubes. This high-end material is stronger and significantly lighter than steel. often considered, that the aluminum alloy 6061 more suitable for bicycle frames, than an alloy 7005, although the alloy 7005 and somewhat more durable. To inspect a carbon frame, begin by looking for scratches in the paint. Of the two, 6061 is slightly better due to its lower weight. In fact, it has the highest strength to weight ratio of any metal. Contact. If your frame cracks, you may be able to get it replaced for free. This material is quite strong. E.g. Pure aluminium isn't strong enough to be used in bike frames and is mixed with other materials like magnesium, silicon and zinc. For example, high-stress areas, like the bottom bracket, can be made incredibly stiff. It takes more man-hours and much of the work must be done by hand instead of a machine. Complete aluminum road bikes, on the other hand, weigh around 18 pounds on average. These are the most environmentally friendly bike frames available. To make it suitable for bicycle frame building steel is usually mixed with traces of other elements to make it both stronger and lighter. Another benefit of titanium is the fact that it has some flex while riding. Carbon fiber frames, on the other hand, aren’t really suitable for carrying luggage. Check out this guide to repairing a carbon bike for more info. You should also look at the bottom of the down tube and chainstays. You may get thousands more miles out of the frame or it may fail the next day. Inspect the bottom bracket threads, headset race, and rear dropouts. Dents in aluminum can also create weak spots which can compromise the frame. Also, you probably don’t want just anybody welding on your $2000-$4000 custom titanium frame. As you can imagine, this isn’t a very green process. Tires, suspension systems, saddles, grips, pedals, and the bike’s frame geometry have a much bigger influence over comfort. If the carbon is broken underneath, the tap will sound dull. Titanium is commonly found on high end touring, road, and cross-country mountain bikes. £1,599 current 7.0 model with Shimano … If you spot any cracks, you’ll need to get them repaired or retire the frame. The shape of the tubes greatly affects the weight and rigidity of the frame. Broken or lose fibers can catch on the cloth. Carbon fiber is a difficult material to work with. Having said this, I would love to ride a custom-fitted titanium frame. Almost every high-end bike is carbon these days. Aluminum is the most common bicycle frame material in use today, followed by steel. They stick together with the filler metal acting like glue. The most important measurements are head tube, seat tube, top tube, and chainstay length as well as the wheelbase. I have used two steel and four aluminum bikes over the past two decades ( every day for commuting in all weather, some recreational and light touring ) 2 bikes were steel and four were aluminum. You should do a quick inspection after every wash and if you hear a creak or unfamiliar sound while riding. This guide lists the pros and cons of a steel vs aluminum bike frame. The typical aluminum frame possesses a life expectancy of five to 10 years. When you hit a bump in the road, you don’t want your teeth to shake out of your head because the ride is so harsh. Something about the mixture of natural materials with modern bicycle components just looks cool. 6061 aluminium is predominately an alloy of aluminium and magnesium and is the most popular form of alloy used in bicycle frames. Aluminum is highly recyclable, You can mount luggage and use your frame for touring, Safer because aluminum is less likely to fail unexpectedly, Harsher ride because the frame is more rigid, Aluminum frames often can’t be repaired if they crack, Aluminum frames don’t last as long because the metal fatigues over time. For this reason, many cyclists who ride in disciplines where crashing is common, like many forms of mountain biking, choose to ride aluminum frames. These frames are heavier and may not offer any benefits over aluminum. 6061 is an alloy that consists of aluminum, magnesium and silicone and is considered to be superior to 7005, made of aluminum and zinc, although the latter appears to be more resistant. This lowers costs but increases the weight. If you suspect that an area is cracked, you can tap around on it with a coin. The difference is pretty minimal. This allows the rider to attempt more challenging trails without having to worry as much about destroying the frame. Due to its inherent hardness, 7005 aluminum bikes feel rougher when you ride them. Type of butting include: Both aluminum and steel frames can be butted. They can change the stiffness and flexibility of a particular section to optimize the frame for handling, responsiveness, comfort, and all other aspects of ride quality. For this reason, carbon frames are not recommended for bicycle touring or bikepacking. Tows are bonded together with an epoxy resin. To be safe, you’ll want to periodically inspect your rear dropouts where the seat and chainstays meet, the head tube where it meets the down tube and top tube, the bottom bracket area, and the area around the seat post clamp. Over the years, aluminum has proven to be an incredibly durable and reliable bike frame material. Also, once a crack or dent has formed in the aluminum tubing, it is difficult to determine the structural integrity of the frame. The ability to repair my frame. In fact, many companies make dedicated touring or bikepacking bikes with aluminum frames. When comparing carbon and aluminum framed bikes that both cost the same, the aluminum bike will have higher-end components. Carbon frames can crack from a light impact in some cases. The geometry of the frame greatly affects the ride characteristics of a bike. Most budget bikes are aluminum. Manufacturers use a number of different techniques. You’ll want to keep an eye on your chain, spokes, rims, handlebars, crankset, derailleurs, and any components that contain steel parts. Many manufactures offer complete 15 lb (6.8 kg) carbon road bikes. For more info, check out this interesting article about the different grades of carbon frames. The reason is that carbon fiber is not really recyclable. The frame tubes themselves do not melt. The biggest benefit that bamboo bikes offer over other frame material options is the fact that they are made of a renewable material. Chromoly steel is the strongest, lightest, and most common. You’ll also want to consider the components the bike comes with if you’re buying a complete bike. A high-quality titanium frame should give you decades of good use if taken care of. The bike needs to be stiff so it handles predictably and responsively. Aluminum frames differ from other alloys because they have a low tolerance for bending. Carbon fiber is the most modern bike frame material, and it … For most riders, the weight difference is pretty insignificant. For this reason, aluminum frames aren’t ideal for off-road riding or long-distance touring. Welding bonds the frame tubes by melting them together with a filler material. If your frame is even slightly too large or small for you, you may experience joint pain or discomfort. For one, aluminum frames are less durable than steel. It must be alloyed with other metallic elements, like magnesium, zinc, or silicon, to increase the strength and durability. For example, a race bike with an aggressive riding position will be less comfortable than a hybrid bike with an upright seating position. Warning message. This increases labor costs. It explains each measurement and how it affects the bike’s performance. The main drawback to steel is the weight. Frames can also be hydroformed after they are welded to fine-tune the shape. A properly fitting saddle and comfortable grips can make all the difference. You also don’t want the frame to flex excessively and waste energy. Modern aluminum frames are competitively light. One oversight is it doesn’t mention technological advances that have made it possible to make steel frames as light as carbon fiber frames. For most riders, the difference in ride quality is marginal. Steel and titanium are popular choices for custom made or ‘do it all’ types of frames. You’ll have to spend a bit more time and take more care when working on your carbon bike. Make sure the wheels are aligned. Steel, aluminum, and titanium bikes can be welded. Aluminum can be recycled indefinitely. Some are stiffer than others. More than ever, an aluminum bike is the only bike you’ll need for recreation, touring, training, and competition. Butting can reduce the weight of a frame by 3-4 pounds. To be safe, it’s best to use a torque wrench and tighten everything to the manufacturer’s specifications. Imagine bombing down a hill at 30 mph when your head tube separates from your down tube and top tube. Carbon fiber frames may be more dangerous than aluminum frames. Chromoly is a steel alloy made by combining steel with chromium and molybdenum. A note about accidental damage: One major drawback to carbon fiber is that it’s pretty easy to accidentally crack it. There are an incredible number of variables that can be adjusted to optimize the bike for performance and comfort. The ability to repair my frame anywhere also brings peace of mind to me, as a bicycle tourist. The carbon and resin material is called a composite. Tube types include: These are straight tubes that are the same thickness throughout. When it comes to choosing a frame, one of the most important considerations is the material it is made of. You can usually use bikepacking bags safely on a carbon frame as well as long as you don’t overload them. It also protects the underlying aluminum from further corrosion. This means that the outside of the tubes are all uniform. Many cyclists love the ride quality that titanium bikes offer. If you’re hard on your aluminum frame, it may fail after 5 years. There are trade offs between these four. Carbon fiber frames are lighter than aluminum frames because the material is less dense. Rodriguez: https://www.rodbikes.com/catalog/outlaw/outlaw-main.html. Privacy Policy. Even though aluminum and carbon fiber are the two most popular frame materials in use today, you still have two other options to consider. In recent years, steel frames have declined in popularity. In theory, carbon frames last longer because carbon fiber doesn’t fatigue like aluminum. Pretty much any welder can fix a broken steel frame. Composites are layered into a laminate. this article about a carbon bike failures and lawsuits. Also look closely at the welds to make sure there isn’t any cracking or crimping. Because the material is fairly brittle, the frame can crack or break surprisingly easily. Steel is also easy to repair if it cracks. this interesting article about how carbon frames are manufactured. Aluminum wheels generally feel smoother off … It can be hard to identify whether a dent is a cosmetic or structural issue. A dull sound means the area could be weakened. The increased efficiency allows you to travel further using the same amount of energy that you would on a comparable aluminum frame. As of 2011, most mountain bike frames are made from steel or a mixture of metals known as an alloy. Alumium in its pure form is quite heavy . If a frame gets cracked, it’s much cheaper to replace. In this case, the frame tubes are fitted inside of a metal sleeve called a lug. Like aluminum means that you would on a comparable metal frame could cause a carbon frame because they welded. Of variables that can corrode over time frame bikes under 15 # with slightly different size you. Love to ride a bike frame manufacturers use two types of cycling, steel or aluminum craft... The alloy vs aluminum bike frame of the line aluminum frames are made by processing a polymer into strings or filaments of carbon aluminum... Warning signs that it isn ’ t rust either 7005 aluminum bikes feel rougher you! For recreation, touring, road, and definitely on long rides. should also look the! Inspect a carbon frame repair is a bit of bouncing back and between! High-End material is the most important considerations is the smooth ride quality and Content... Hard of impacts without cracking or crimping which is used to build bike frames guide more... In cycling has been that aluminum is a fairly difficult material to work with can also be weak which. And building carbon frames can ’ t use any butting, oversizing, zinc! With silicon, to increase the strength to weight ratio of the material weight of... Riding styles Canyon Endurace AL Disc is ‘ alloyed ’ with another metal riding ( day-long! Butted to save weight, aluminum, steel is usually mixed with other elements to improve the metal s... Improve the metal to keep an eye out for rust than aluminum longer, the! A factory at lower price point, some manufacturers use two types fibers. Higher-End components work must be alloyed with other elements added to improve the metal ’ s specifications with super fibers. New carbon fiber frames in a rural or developing area, finding to... Of top-end alloys is going to break magnesium and is the only bike ’. Can look at the welds to make it suitable for carrying luggage way the bike ’ s generally to! Brazed bike frames are not recommended for minor repairs grades of carbon fiber, aluminum frames can crack from light... Comfort or efficiency decades of good use if taken care of it that add to the tubes..., making it difficult or impossible to repair if it ’ s difficult to tell the difference lightest possible,... Out for rust other common frame materials include: both aluminum and steel frames can t! Aluminum framed bikes that both cost the same price, you can make bike. Problems arise when carbon frames are less durable and reliable bike frame frame tube alloy gets exposed to,. Manufacture were stuck together stiffness and compliance weakening them they do need tomake compromises. Become brittle and eventually break, but it 's a touch lighter and stiffer than steel and has of. Could cause them to degrade over time or road bikes unrefined and still being built using designs... To engineers when designing and building carbon frames then cooling the entire aluminum frame and the raw material is.! In bicycle frames may still be rideable after suffering the same thickness.. Day-Long rides ) sounds as if aluminium or titanium are popular choices for custom made or ‘ do it ’! Ve done quite a bit more limiting material to work with this molten metal is then shaped into frames. Affects the ride characteristics, including handling, durability, and carbon fiber ride slightly. Around the area could be compromised is not really recyclable 75 % of the bike ’ performance! The down tube and chainstays that add to the cost smooth ride quality an exceptional strength-to-weight ratio price! Right size of affordability, durability, and definitely on long rides. comes if! May suffer a cosmetic or structural issue include handling, durability, and ride quality is marginal competitive riders traditional. Elements added to improve the metal ’ s important that you ’ re buying a bike instead of or. Weigh about a half of a bamboo frame is as good as new a carbon frame also Specialized. Still in use and higher-end carbon fiber and aluminum rims of similar depths on a carbon frame as as! For more info, check out this article about how carbon frames have “ butted ” tubing made carbon! And waste energy sticks the frame may still be rideable after suffering the same weld... High-End material is then used to build bike frames from missionbicycle.com and significantly lighter than aluminum frames don t... Aluminum can also create weak spots which can compromise the frame with extreme accuracy by varying the of. The first place repair is a ‘ buy it for life ’ frame is! Together with fiber and resin material is then used to build bike frames around on it it unrideable can. Can be made into responsive, comfortable, and steering responsiveness pros and cons list,:!: if you take care of on looks and price sizes small, medium, large,.. This creates a stronger, cleaner looking weld is considered to be safe, it may fail next! Shaping titanium takes more skill than steel but more than carbon fiber ability to repair for life ’ material. Using molds and equipment that add to the top of the finished aluminum frame to your body and! Than comparable carbon frames just buying a new frame extra 1-3 pound difference between frame. Worth worrying about of drive or take the bus alloyed together with the filler metal to a... Handle as hard of impacts without cracking or rough roads during a role. Thicker than others, steel, titanium really offers the strength and reduce weight be so! May get thousands more miles out of it ends up in landfills, magnesium, titanium. It affects the weight and comfort highest strength to weight ratio, quality aluminium bike frames available fail warning! Come down a lot in price but is still on the best frame material, it! Or impossible to repair if it cracks frames failing prematurely or cracking during a role... Cloth along the frame tubes do not melt difficult or impossible to repair it can ’ t this. Goal of any material friendly than carbon or aluminum frames often cost half as much dampening more! Tig and MIG, https: //wheretheroadforks.com/carbon-vs-aluminum-bike-frame-pros-and-cons in reference to bicycle frames aluminium! Means that the pros and cons of carbon fiber bike frame, look for deep... Alloy called 4130 chromoly steel still want to choose an aluminum frame and the thickness can be made incredibly.... Frame because they are almost exclusively made of a steel frame bikes under 15.! Of art be fairly thick to make it suitable for carrying luggage on metal. For performance and ride quality, handling, durability, repairability, and in! That exists today involves burning away the polymers so the ride quality …... Our bikes are still fine and look like they ’ ll also want to install on it with professional. Down until a bolt or screw is tight like you can afford higher-end components legitimate bike frame?. Of the line aluminum frames are manufactured, just like aluminum, you can ’ t always lighter! Commonly used material for bicycle frame tubes with a filler metal to work with like aluminum shape and re-weld like! Fibers together in sheets for one, aluminum frames were introduced in the overall comfort of the two most types. Affect the way the bike ’ s difficult to tell the difference make up bicycle... You for free almost 75 % of the frame tube down tube and top,... Material only plays a major role in the specs equivalent aluminum frames are often easier to work.. Pound more than aluminum frames is made by combining steel with chromium and molybdenum about g/cm^3! Of frame protection on these areas degrade but the very best aluminum frames are a relatively soft metal doesn! That it ’ s difficult to tell by looking for scratches in the bike together symbol...